Monday, August 4, 2014

How DNA finally proved my long-suspected connection to Cumbria


The following article was first published in the August 2014 edition of the Newsletter of the Cumbria Family History Society, and is re-printed below with the permission of the editor   

How DNA has finally proved my long-suspected connection to Cumbria

Home of John Lockhart - Kirkandrews-Upon-Esk
As a long time researcher and professional genealogist, the origins of my great, great grandfather, Alexander Lockhart presented me with a challenge I could not seem to overcome. Ironically, it had been easier for me to research his wife’s story. Women’s lives are traditionally more difficult to trace due to name changes, lack of visibility in various records, and in this case a move from one country to another.  I published her story in Marie Richenet—From Switzerland to Ireland—her Amazing Life Story. I was able to trace her family to the 1600’s in Switzerland and then follow her to Ireland where she came as a governess to the three daughters of Lord John George Beresford, brother of the Archbishop. She and the girls lived primarily at the Archbishop’s palace in Armagh.

It was here that she would have met Alexander Lockhart, who first appears at their 1826 marriage record in St. Patrick’s Cathedral (COI) in Armagh. Alexander’s occupation was Gardener to His Grace the Archbishop. Sadly, no reference was given to his father’s name or his place of origin. However, his status as gardener to the Archbishop indicated a significant degree of training and experience as well as the connections and references required to obtain such an elevated position. This marriage was also written up in the Belfast Newsletter at a time when most marriages did not appear in newspapers. Subsequent references to Alexander in Irish records are scant although he was identified as a gentleman on the affidavits when his son Alexander entered the practice of law. The most significant reference to him was the inscription on his tombstone in Belfast, indicating that he was 60 at the time of his death on 6 January, 1848. This would have given him a birth year of about 1788. But the question was—where?

Thanks to present-day access to a wide range of data the records many Lockhart families in England and Ireland were searched for clues. A most intriguing family was found in Kirkandrews-Upon-Esk. On 1 April 1787 an Alexander Lockhart was born to John Lockhart (1759—1841) and Margaret Story (1757—11 April, 1787). Margaret clearly died as a result of his birth and then subsequently this Alexander disappears from all local records. There is no evidence of a marriage, a death, an emigration or an entry in any census. His father John went on to marry again and have more children, including a son Robert. John had also had previous relationships with a Mary Carruthers and a Janet Peal. 

Of great interest to me was the family occupation as gardeners. The father, John, was a cottage gardener on the grounds of Netherby, the estate of Sir James Graham. The Carlisle Patriot of September 23, 1839 and again of September 5, 1840 quotes from speeches given by Sir James Graham at the annual meetings of the Netherby Agricultural Society. Both refer to prizes he won for best-kept cottages and gardens. In addition, it is noted that he is the father of the famous David Lockhart who had gone on to become “the botanical gardener to the government garden of Trinidad – a large and important public establishment connected with the cultivation of the finest plants of tropical climates.”

Now thoroughly intrigued by this family, I researched it extensively online and then onsite in Kirkandrews-Upon-Esk and Longtown with the assistance of Bridget Casson and William Bundred. Together we searched for any documentation which might prove a link between the Alexander, born 1787 and the Alexander, born about 1788 and buried in Belfast. None was located, but the research did illustrate that gardening was the profession of a large part of this family. From his first relationship with Mary Carruthers, a grandson, Robert (1804—1881) was a master gardener. From his marriage to Janet Paisley, a son Robert (1803—1875) was a master gardener, living near Netherby in the 1841 and 1851 census. Robert’s son John (1827—1844) was a flower gardener at Netherby Hall in 1841, and a son Robert was assistant under gardener at Netherby in 1851.
The most prominent of John’s sons was David Lockhart, whose life has been written up in the Oxford Dictionary of National of Biography. He had evidently been trained at Kew Gardens in London as he was sent out by them to the Congo on an expedition in 1816. He survived and was sent to Trinidad where he became the Superintendant of the Royal Botanic Gardens. He remained at this position until 1845 and is buried in a cemetery on the site of these gardens. Had his brother Alexander also gone with him to Kew?

There seemed to be strong circumstantial evidence that the Alexander, born in Kirkandrews and my Alexander, are one and the same, but could this be proven? The latest tool in the arsenal of genealogists and family historians is DNA. Of course the results depend upon who has chosen to be tested and how broad the database is. I chose to be tested with www.familytreeDna.com as well as www.23andme.com. The cost was reasonable and provided solid confirmation of relationships to several others on various of my family lines whom I had known or suspected might be related. But could any DNA results link me to the Lockharts of Kirkandrews?
First I had to try to find living descendants of others in those family lines who would agree to be tested. I developed a complete family tree and posted it online on Ancestry, keeping it separate from my own tree. To increase my expertise and understanding I also attended a DNA course. I was fortunate to locate some descendants of Robert Lockhart (1803—1875) in Manitoba, Canada. One member agreed to be tested (I paid) and we eagerly awaited the results. They were inconclusive, which we knew might be possible, since we were searching for matching results from half  brothers four generations later. Then a few months ago I located a descendant of David Lockhart, the botanist. Bart had not known about his illustrious ancestor and was most anxious to help me with the search. Again I paid for the test which had to be shipped to England. 

This time we were successful! I can say this as I have had the results evaluated by my DNA class instructor. Bart had a very strong match to my cousin Diane (3rd cousin once removed) in Australia. She is descended from Alexander and Marie’s eldest son John, whereas I am descended from their second son (another Alexander). Because of the manner in which DNA is distributed, this man, Bart, did not match me directly, nor several other of my cousins, but the match to Diane is considered statistically significant. This is not the place to get technical, but for those who might be interested the match was 11.9 cM (centimorgans) on chromosome #13. At the same time, Bart matched other matches of mine (relationships not yet proven) who also matched Diane, all on exactly the same place and for the same strong amount on chromosome #13. Eventually this triangulation of matches confirmed that there is a relationship, as the matches are all consistent, all in the same range and the right size for going back the number of generations we would be looking at for descendants of half siblings. 

To add to our discovery we re-examined the earlier results from the Canadian testee, Gwen, and she matches four of my other Lockhart cousins, all on chromosome #4. The matches are not strong, and by themselves would not be conclusive enough evidence, but with the other data they support our finding because again the chromosomes and segments are consistent in the same manner.  
I am now in the happy situation of being able to say that Diane and Bart and I all share a common Cumbrian ancestor, John Lockhart. I am even happier that I can show that my great, great grandfather, Alexander, was the half-brother of David Lockhart, the famous botanist. John’s father was Alexander Lockhart (DOB between 1709 to 1729 to 2 June 1782) in Moat, so this discovery has taken me even further back in my ancestral research. Now my goal is to get this family back across the border to its Scottish origins.

                                                                             

Sunday, December 8, 2013

No longer a mystery - Marie's husband - Alexander Lockhart



Alexander Lockhart, Sr. – his life


Alexander Lockhart is was an enigma. He is was one of those rare men whose life’s story can primarily be told through the life of his wife Marie whose own life is recounted in Marie Richenet – from Switzerland to Ireland – her Amazing Life Story.  (His family of origin has now been located due to DNA testing - see article above).

A copy of his marriage in The Belfast Newsletter: ”At Armagh, on the 6th inst. By the Rev. C.S. Mangin (sic). Mr Alex Lockhart to Miss Maria Richney(sic).” [1] This marriage was also located in the registers of St. Patrick’s Cathedral, Armagh: “Alexander Lockhart of this Parish of Armagh, Gardener to His Grace the Lord Primate, and Maria (sic) (Marie) Richart (sic) Richenet of this parish were married in this church by license with the consent of "friends", this sixth day of May, 1826, by me Rev. Cosby Stopford Mangan, Witnesses: William Penton, and James Smyth”.[2] Both witnesses were listed as seedsmen in Pigot's 1824 Directory.

 Both Alexander and Marie signed the marriage register themselves. This is the one and only time Alexander's own signature has been seen, and it confirms that both were literate.

At the time of the baptism of Alexander’s first son, John, in Armagh in 1827 [3] Alexander Sr's residence was "the parish of Armagh" and his title was Gardener to his Grace the Lord Primate. The father's abode was "Demesne”, which is the property owned by the Archbishop around the Cathedral. Griffith's Valuation for the parish of Armagh indicated a Townland called Demesne, the property of the Archbishop for all of Ireland. It is described as consisting of "The Palace, offices, gate-lodges, gardener's house and land". It is therefore most likely that the Lockharts were living in the "gardener's house" in the demesne of the Archbishop of Armagh.

The next reference to Alexander was the 15 April 1829 baptism of their second son, Alexander, in St. Marylebone Church, London, England. [4] The family abode was Great Marylebone Street (now New Cavendish Street) and Alexander’s profession was given as Gardener. This church and residence are directly across Marylebone Road from the famous Regent’s Park which was being developed at that time. This might suggest the reason for their move to London.

However, no other records in London have been located to indicate how long they may have lived there. In 1838 a New Testament was given to Marie in Rockingham, County Roscommon, the residence of Lord Lorton. It is therefore probable that Alexander was with her and was performing the role of gardener to this aristocratic family. It is not known how long he and Marie spent at Rockingham.

At some point in the 1840’s the family moved to Belfast where a reference is found for Alex Lockhart on Shankhill Road in the 1846-47 Henderson’s Directory.[5] Griffith Valuation for Belfast lists Alexander Lockhart as the immediate Lessor (Landlord) in the Parish of Shankhill, Townland of Townparks, for 33 Church Lane (Shankhill Parish, St. George’s Ward), shop and stores occupied by James Killen & John P. Gibson.[6]

There are no other known direct references to Alexander apart from the document signed when his son Alexander entered his training for the practice of law on 19 March, 1856 Belfast by becoming an apprentice to William Michael Moore. The affidavit of parent was signed by Marie Lockhart, of 34 Arthur St., Belfast, Co. Antrim, widow, stating that she is the mother of Alexander Lockhart. Alexander, also of 34 Arthur Street, Belfast, states that his father was Alexander Lockhart, deceased, Gentleman.

Alexander died on 6 Jan 1848 at the age of 60 in Belfast, Ireland. The burial records of Christ Church have not survived, and strangely no newspaper carried his obituary or even a death notice. His death information was obtained from his tombstone, erected probably a number of years later by his son Alexander. The tombstone reads:

Lockhart Family burying place of Alexander Lockhart. In memory of his father Alexander who died 06 January 1848, aged 60 years. And his mother Marie who died 12 January 1862 aged 64 years. Also his daughter Margaret who died 17 January 1870 aged 2 years and 2 months. Also his son John who died 13 November 1886 aged 23 years. And also of his beloved wife Margaret who died 18 October 1887, aged 60 years. And of the above named Alexander Lockhart who died 31 August 1892 aged 63 years. Also his son Henry who died 18 January 1902 aged 36 years. Also his son Alexander Agnew Lockhart who died 09 October 1925 aged 63 years. "I know that my Redeemer liveth." Job 19, 25.[7]

Shankill graveyard adjoins St. Matthew's Church in Shankill Road, the area where Alexander and Marie first lived when they came to Belfast. It is a very old cemetery and was the closest cemetery to Christ Church where subsequent family records indicate the Lockharts attended. The tombstone has not survived but fortunately the inscriptions were recorded some years ago. Alexander’s burial in this graveyard led to Marie's there as well, and so it became the future burial place of all of the 18th & 19th Century Lockhart and Agnew (his daughter-in-law’s family) burials.

In the family’s possession is a small note book with entries starting in 1827. It very much appears to have been a gardener's note book, with references to various bulbs and flowers, measurements, etc.  

What strange mixed messages we appear to have been left with. No known date or place of birth or family of origin. No records of the significant education and training which would have been required for a gardener to rise up through the ranks. Yet, Alexander reached the level of head gardener to the Primate of all Ireland and thereafter in all probability held a similar or substantial position with respect to the design and development of the famous landscape at Lord Lorton’s estate at Rockingham.  Those in such positions were highly educated men and members of what we would call a professional class. His marriage was announced in the newspaper, which is considered unusual and significant by John McCabe, a leading Irish genealogist, and Alexander’s son became a solicitor in the time when upward social mobility was not the norm.

During his life Alexander also knew or came into contact with several notable people of high standing. This included Lord John George Beresford, the Archbishop of all Ireland, his sister; Lady Anne, both of whom resided in the Palace demesne in Armagh; Lord George Thomas Beresford, their brother, who along with his daughters were frequent visitors to the Palace; Harriet Beresford Dunbar, niece of the Archbishop and her husband, George Dunbar, and finally, Henry Russell, founder of a well-known Belfast legal firm.

Additional on-going research, including DNA, may prove the current hypothesis that Alexander was from Cumbria in northern England. But conjecture cannot give us specific details about Alexander’s early life and family. What will help, however, is an understanding of the world of gardening in the 18th century, and the role which head gardeners played in society where they were highly thought of by the upper class and were much in demand. A head gardener would not be equated with a member of the labouring class and indeed often held a fairly esteemed position in society. As a professional or landscape gardener Alexander may have worked for his own account, or for a particular family or both.  He might have moved around on a seasonal basis which could explain why he has been so difficult to trace.  The plethora of early gardening publications and organizations should have made it easy to find Alexander – but – so many potentially relevant records have been lost or destroyed. What can we therefore learn that may help fill in the gaps in Alexander’s life?

It will be helpful to keep in mind that at the time of Alexander’s marriage in 1826, where he appeared full-blown as a head gardener, he was 39 years of age. This suggests a prior significant personal history of education, training and experience. In the family today there is a miniature oil painting of a handsome young Alexander Lockhart, very formally dressed in blue suit jacket and high neck cravat. The style of dress suggests that it may have been painted about 1810 and would be an indication of someone of sufficient status to have been able to afford to have such a painting completed.

It is also helpful to known that extensive research in a wide range of available records in Ireland, including wills, has never been able to connect Alexander to any other Lockhart families in Ireland. At the same time, the Alexander Lockhart from Cumbria above was born 1 April, 1787, the son of John Lockhart, a prize-winning cottage gardener on the grounds of Netherby, the estate of Sir James Graham in Kirkandrews-Upon-Esk, Cumbria, England. This is a very close approximation to the date of birth of 1788 suggested from the Belfast tombstone of Alexander Lockhart.  This Alexander’s mother, Margaret Story, died 10 days after his birth and he subsequently disappears from all local records. He was not found in any further census, marriage or death records. This absence could tie him to the Alexander who arrived in Armagh in 1826.

Of even greater significance is that this would make him the half-brother of David Lockhart,
the famous botanist, born 1786, whose early training is presumed to have taken place in London’s Royal Botanic Gardens in Kew.  Perhaps Sir James Graham, who was also a London MP, might have been instrumental in arranging contacts and introductions. We know that in 1839 Sir James was very impressed by the later accomplishments of David Lockhart and gave a glowing speech in his honour upon his visit from Trinidad, where he had become Superintendent of the Botanical Garden.[8] This possible link to David Lockhart and Kew Gardens was a helpful place to begin our wider search into the world of gardening.



Chapter two – Alexander’s Career as Gardener

“In the first half of the nineteenth century the word ‘gardener’ did not simply mean someone who enjoyed gardening; it invariably meant a professional gardener, properly trained”. …Anyone other than a professional would be described as simply ‘an amateur’ or be given a specific name in the context of gardening, such as florist or botanist’. If the meaning of ‘gardener’ is not understood much of what is written in gardening literature of the time may be misconstrued”. Anne Wilkinson, The Victorian Gardener: the Growth of Gardening and the Floral World

Head Gardeners – status and role

Head gardeners were generally regarded as men of great moral fibre and upstanding character, according to Toby Musgrave who added that “the head gardener emerged as a man of influence within the spheres of horticulture and botany during the seventeenth and ...the eighteenth century”.[9] The aristocracy and the landed gentry had long used their estates as a means of displaying their wealth, but the industrial revolution’s newly wealthy industrialists, financiers and merchants led to the establishment of many more large estates. In all situations the main aspect of these status symbols was the garden which was a means of demonstrating one’s learning and financial success. The responsibility to create and maintain such displays of one-upmanship became the head gardener’s.[10]
 
Musgrave further points out as the job of professional gardeners was an esteemed position in society, any applicant would have required a sound reference, preferably from a well-known head gardener or a recommendation from the current employer. It was also not uncommon for visiting guests to poach their host’s head gardener. Word-of-mouth recommendations became very valuable due to the landed gentry’s extensive social networks. Most head gardeners’ pedigrees included training in the most prestigious gardens such as a royal residence, an established stately home or even a Botanic Garden. Gardeners with specific botanical knowledge were a prestigious acquisition for any estate owner and an apprenticeship served at one of the Royal Botanic Gardens meant that the fully qualified gardener would be much in demand for his skill and knowledge.[11]
 
Responsibilities

The head gardener was, in effect, the managing director of a small to medium-sized complex business. He could appoint and manage his own staff over which he had complete authority. He would not be seen participating in the hard physical tasks of his staff. His job was to supervise and inspect and plan the grand formal gardens, pleasure grounds and conservatories to ensure they were running efficiently, to make sure they were productive and to maintain records of planting and produce supplied to the house.[12] To effectively and successfully manage a sizeable establishment required the continued application of superb horticultural and management skills as well as the self-discipline to continue to improve and develop one’s own skills. The wealth of new plants brought to Britain by various plant hunters also presented regular new challenges as these plants required careful and skillful nurturing to survive.

Musgrave provided a more comprehensive description of the role of the head gardener: “ to ensure that the formal gardens juxtaposed to the house and wider pleasure grounds looked at their peak whatever the season or the weather…to ensure the grounds reflected or set the latest style …to ensure the ornamental gardens were filled with the latest, rarest and most expensive plants… to fill the glasshouses and conservatories with rare plants in their prime…to ensure kitchen gardens produced the blooms and foliage that he carefully transformed into elaborate decorations to grace the house..to cultivate the greatest diversity of vegetables and fruits to the highest level of perfection… in and out of season, so that the dining table …was laden with the unusual and the tasty”[13]

The head gardener had also, of course, to meet his employer’s expectations including designing seasonal planting schemes for the formal beds and terraces. The year-round nature of gardening required that all gardening activities would be carried out at the appropriate time and to the expected standards. He was also responsible for good relations with the domestic staff of the house. Because of his level of education, expertise and independence the head gardener was considered a class of servant above the rest and in the social hierarchy of an estate meant that he ranked equally with the butler, housekeeper or cook.

Head gardeners would normally have commanded the respect and loyalty of their employers however they also often received far less than their due, given their achievements and successes, and their high level of expertise, experience and management abilities. The horticultural press wrote that a head gardener required “incomparably greater application of mind than that of a butler, and a gardener is also expected to have attained a greater stock of general knowledge than the other, and not to be behind him or any servant in attention to his duty, fidelity to his master’s interest and general trustworthiness”.[14] However, Musgrave indicates that “praise for the moral fibre and intellectual standing of head gardeners was frequently accompanied by complaints that they were not accorded their true position in society, nor were they paid sufficiently well, often preventing their rise through the social ranks”.[15]

Education and Training

This highlights the question of Alexander’s whereabouts prior to 1826. Where did he complete his training and his apprenticeship? It is known that David, his supposed half-brother, had been connected to the Royal Botanic Gardens in Kew from where he was sent on a plant-hunting expedition to the Congo in 1816. An obvious source of information seemed to be these Kew records but their archivist and librarian indicated that the news was not good. No records at Kew cover the early period when David and Alexander might have been there. This is due to the fact that at that time and until 1841 the gardens were still the property of the Crown and therefore the records for the late 18th & 19th century are held at the Royal Archives in Windsor. It was disappointing to then learn that  unfortunately, the Royal Archives do not hold any records of gardeners for this early period either. Sadly, the early staffing records from this period – the papers related to Kew and its then Curator, William Townsend Aiton were destroyed. The reason is unknown, but a later successor to the role of Curator, John Smith, report that the papers were burnt by John Aiton, William Townsend Aiton’s brother. However, this is not proof that he was not there”. It certainly is a shame that the earliest records of Staff at Kew were sadly destroyed. I am very glad to say however that we do hold quite a lot of material related to David Lockhart. As you can no doubt see from his entry in Ray Desmond's Dictionary of British and Irish botanists and horticulturists he was clearly an important member of his profession”.[16]
 
Therefore, Alexander may have trained at the Royal Botanic Gardens in Kew along with David Lockhart, but we will never be able to prove or disprove this. However, to have been acceptable to Kew or any other establishment he would still have had to go to through a hierarchical training process. Dr. Charles Nelson, a well known Irish horticulturist with whom extensive correspondence has been undertaken, explained in several emails that there were no "schools" of gardening; training was by serving time in large established gardens attached to a large house or demesnes or in several botanic gardens. Only after those stages could a man call himself a gardener, and he may have worked many more years before becoming a head gardener.[17]  Nelson indicated that Alexander would have had to go through the three preliminary stages, and most probably did not begin anywhere near Armagh. He even mused that he may not have been Irish at all. 

Professor Sir Roderick Floud in a June 2013 lecture pointed out that “the aspirant gardener, later to aspire to the heights of a head gardener, was expected to become a skilled botanist and horticulturalist. Employers were enjoined to provide a library of books on plants and their cultivation, which the apprentices and junior gardeners were expected to study in their spare time, after working hours…formal apprenticeship was followed by jobs in a variety of gardens, gradually working up through an hierarchy of posts…Biographies show gardeners moving all around the country from job to job, before achieving their first post as head gardener in their 30’s or 40’s. Many remained unmarried through their early careers.[18]The timing indicated here fits very well when we remember that Alexander would have been 39 at the time of his marriage.

Musgrave quotes John Claudius Loudan, the most- distinguished gardening author of the age, who vehemently declared that “that the good head gardener had to be possessed of a good and broad education in addition to fine horticultural skills.”[19] He said that a “gardener must not only be a good practical botanist but possess some knowledge of chemistry, mechanics, and even of the principles of taste...he must write a good hand, spell and point correctly, and compose a good letter. Drawing... is indispensible...as well as sketching landscape, and some knowledge of French”. [20]
Musgrave elaborated that “To reach the elevated position of a head gardener began aged twelve or fourteen when a young lad, already in possession of a good primary education, embarked on a traineeseship” that would moved through pot boy, then a year or so as an apprentice gaining an understanding in the different divisions of the garden – the ornamental grounds, the kitchen garden, the glasshouses, followed after four years or so to the position of journeyman gardener. He could move from one establishment to another , changing jobs to further develop skills in the various disciplines of horticulture. After two or three years a talented journeyman could then take a head gardener’s post in a small garden, perhaps with a staff or two or could move to another large establishment as a foreman of one of the garden departments. The next step would be that of general foreman or deputy head gardener before being fully qualified as a head gardener”.[21]
 
Musgrave explained that it was taken for granted that before entering a garden an apprentice was possessed of a tolerable school education including writing, arithmetic, geometry, drawing and some rudiments of Latin. Once in a position during the day the apprentice and journeyman both had to work and master the diverse practical skills of gardening taught by means of instruction and experience – long ten hour days, six days  a week. Evenings were dedicated to self-improvement through the study of both horticultural theory and foreign languages, arithmetic and book keeping, mathematics, drawing, geography and history, oral and political science, natural philosophy and chemistry, natural history, general knowledge and professional books as well as general and professional periodicals.[22] Loudon, in 1845, laid out more topics such as geography of natural history, geology, meteorology and physiology, practical geometry and trigonometry, hydrostatics and hydraulics, land-surveying, levelling, planning and mapping, architectural drawing and perspective.[23] Others insisted on English grammar, geology, botany, vegetable physiology, horticultural chemistry, physical geography, entomology, land measuring, architectural drawing, letter writing, and penmanship.

These academic demands are clearly significant and indeed it is known that when David Lockhart died he left £100 to his home school in Kirkandrews-Upon-Esk, perhaps an indication that he (and Alexander) had received a solid foundation upon which to build their subsequent learning.  Documents from the Netherby estate also indicate that Sir James Graham was very supportive of educational activities on his estate.

The Archbishop’s Palace in Armagh

Dr. Charles Nelson is very familiar with the Archbishop’s demesne and garden in Armagh. He indicated that the Palace in Armagh was not a small house, nor would the archbishop's household (including garden and farm staff) have been small. There was a large walled demesne to look after, a large walled garden, and glasshouses. One man could never have looked after such a place and never would have in those days. There was a garden house and there would have been other staff accommodation, including a gate-lodge. “The point is this - the Archbishop's garden was not a small affair, and one man would not have run it.”[24]
 
We know that Alexander is described as Gardener to His Grace the Lord Primate in the baptismal and church records. Although he is not described as the head gardener, the former designation and title clearly indicate a specific position. Additional research has located the names of the other head gardeners to the Archbishop in the years up to 1826 and following 1829, so we can fairly safely assume that Alexander was, in fact, the head gardener while at Armagh.[25] Interestingly, in the 1834 obituary of James Elles, identified as gardener to the Archbishop from 1830, his education was outlined. He had learned Latin and Greek in grammar school, after which he became a  botanist and a cultivator of flowers. He had been gardener to the Marquess of Bath for ten years before coming to Armagh, where he died four years later.[26]
 
Botanic Gardens

Botanic gardens became popular in the nineteen century when plant collecting occurred on an increasing scale worldwide. There were other training or work opportunities within Ireland for Alexander, for example, The National Botanic Gardens in Glasnevin, Dublin, also known as Royal Botanic Gardens, was founded in 1790. Dr. Charles Nelson has researched its history and advised that no Lockhart was ever at the National Botanic Gardens according to his Occasional Paper 4.[27]
There was also Trinity College Botanic Garden in Dublin where Archbishop Beresford, was, in fact, the Chancellor of the university from 1851 to 1862. They too do not have early staff lists.
The Belfast Botanic Gardens were established in 1827 but an examination of their available records has not located Alexander Lockhart after 1829 when he may have returned to Ireland from England. Interestingly, it has been learned that until 1864 the affairs of the Company were run by a committee with headquarters at 47 Arthur St.[28] Of note is the fact that Marie and her son Alexander lived at no. 34 Arthur Street from 1856 to 1862.

Palm houses and hot houses

Hothouses, known as conservatories, became popular everywhere. These greatly extended the growing season and allowed for a wide variety of fruit and vegetables for the family table as well as unusual flowers for decorating the house. [29] A large glass house was built by the Archbishop at Armagh in 1826, the time of Alexander’s presence there. Then, during the 1830’s and 1840’s, the time when it is believed that  Alexander was resident gardener at Lord Lorton’s estate, Rockingham, some significant features were added including a vast walled garden with extensive glasshouses. It appears that Alexander had skills and experience in this area. The extensive gardens and the attention paid to the importance of the demesne grounds of the aristocracy reinforces the assumption that Alexander’s skills as a gardener would have been the reason for a move to Rockingham. A recommendation from a former employer such as the Archbishop would have carried weight with someone like Lord Lorton. 

At the same time large palm houses made of glass and cast iron were developed and installed in rapid succession in various parts of Ireland and England. Many of the individuals involved in these developments would have been contemporaries of Alexander. The Dublin based famous ironmaster Richard Turner completed the wings of the Palm House at Belfast in 1840, the curvilinear greenhouses at Glasnevin 1848 and also designed the iron work for the Great Palm House at Kew.[30] In 1837 Joseph Paxton, head gardener to the Duke of Devonshire, built the largest glasshouse in the world, 277 ft. by 123 ft. and followed this up in 1851 by what eventually became the Crystal Palace of London.[31]The names of other individuals continue to crop up in the world of gardening from this period, including the famous English architect and garden designer Decimus Burton (1800-1881) who designed the Palm House at Kew and worked on Regent’s Park. It must have been a stimulating time to be involved in the world of gardening.

The literature of the day indicates that there was a constant interchange of individuals in the gardening world between England, Scotland and Ireland. Gardeners and gardening writers in Alexander’s time, such as J.C. Loudon, travelled and wrote extensively. There was very close contact between the great gardens in Britain, notably Kew as well as Dublin and Edinburgh. Head gardeners also moved around between the three countries. The majority of well-known gardeners and landscape gardeners were Scottish, often from gardening families, and left a strong legacy in places such as Glasnevin, Trinity College Dublin, Belfast Botanic Garden.  Landscape designers and architects such as John Nash (1752-1835), and John Sutherland (1745-1826) left their mark in all of these countries. 

The Royal Horticultural Society of Ireland (RHSI)

A professional society known as The Royal Horticultural Society of Ireland was founded in 1816 by Dublin gardeners “to protect and promote the science of horticulture” . From then till 1830 it was run by gardeners of the gentry.  In 1835 the  professional gardeners formed their own society, the Practical Floral and Horticultural Society because the gentry, rather than the gardeners, had taken over the RHSI. It was different from its counterparts in England and Scotland in that it was an association of “professional gardeners, not of amateur horticulturalists or landed gentry”. [32]
Again, there is no list of early members. The Archivist has indicated that the earliest membership records are from 1897, and minute books up to 1842 are no longer available. 

The Royal Horticultural Society of Ireland was, like everything else, affected by social, cultural and political changes in Ireland. A very poignant story is outlined from the account of one of their shows:
 “ At the Autumn Show of 1849 there was unprecedented tumult. As the show came towards its end there was a sudden rush toward the fruit and vegetable exhibits and a section of the attendance fought with each other as they tried to grab as much of the produce as possible. The Irish Farmers’ Gazette reported that “the scene of Thursday evening last outbeggers description for vulgarity, ferocity and a total disregard to anything approaching the most remote degree to decency and honesty…”  “This was during one of the most calamitous years of the ‘Great Famine’. During the week of the Society’s Autumn Show over one million persons were being maintained in the Poor Law workhouses or on outdoor relief because they would otherwise have starved to death. Yet whilst the famine arose from the loss of the potato crop, the Freeman’s Journal describing the exhibit at another of the Society’s shows during this period pointed out that “…the specimens of the potato and the several varieties of table succulents …were all of the best kind and in great profusion:. In the circumstances it is easy to pardon the behaviour of the hungry citizens of Dublin”. [33]

Alexander’s time in London

We have already learned that in 1829 Alexander and Marie were living in London. The reason for their move is not known but an intriguing tidbit has been mentioned in a book written at the Archbishop’s Palace in Armagh by Eleanor Alexander, the daughter of a later Archbishop. The main character is Lady Anne, sister to Archbishop Beresford from Alexander and Marie’s time. She is described as “a most autocratic personage; one who could not get on with the head gardener, and had to have her own man, her own garden, her own key, her own walk – everything for her very own proud self.”[34]  If this referred to Alexander it could indicate why the situation might have become very unpleasant for him and precipitated a move away.

Alexander and Marie lived on Great Marylebone Street (now New Cavendish Street) and Alexander’s profession was given as gardener. This residence was around the corner from the famous Regent’s Park, originally known as Marylebone Park. Within the inner circle of the park was a private nursery known as Jenkins Nursery, the lease having been taken up in 1826.[35]
The park was commenced in 1812[36] and during the 1820’s and 1830’s was under extensive development. The scope of the activities being undertaken could certainly have provided a role for Alexander’s skill and expertise.

In 1828 the Zoological Gardens were established in Regent’s Park. We learn that “Apart altogether from the world-famous collection of animals that is to be seen here, these grounds present a remarkably pleasing and natural appearance, which is largely brought about by the numerous well-arranged shrubberies and flower beds that confront one in almost every direction”.[37]  The archivist of the Zoological Society of London, Regents Park, London, Michael Palmer, advised that he could not find anything about Alexander in the development of the Zoological Gardens (1820’s – 1840’s) nor in any membership lists or employee lists (1820-1840’s).[38] Once again we find Decimus Burton on staff as architect in 1832 where he was commissioned to design some of the gardens and some of the buildings for the animals.

 In 1839 the Royal Botanic Society was founded in the park. Eighteen acres which had been leased to Jenkins, the nursery gardener who had supplied trees for the Park, were rented for the society, and again Decimus Burton was the architect who laid out the Gardens.[39] This was located in the Inner Circle, the former Jenkin’s Nursery and is now Queen Mary’s Gardens (it is not related to Royal Botanic Gardens in Kew).

But it was the work of the Regent’s architect, John Nash, which was changing this area even more significantly. His proposals for terraced housing led to extensive upheaval in the park, and “for several years after the spring of 1830 the public were restricted to the use of the roads and paths only…while tree-planting and general ground-work improvements were being carried out.” [40]
Alexander could have been part of these activities. Alternatively, had he gone to London to work in the Jenkins Nursery? No records have been found to substantiate either concept. 

Summary

The extensive appendix and bibliography indicate the level and scope of research which has been undertaken to try to learn more about Alexander Lockhart and his gardening career. New record sources are becoming available frequently so a keen look-out is being kept in this regard and we may hope to learn more about Alexander and his life. In addition, the DNA research being undertaken may at least prove (or disprove) the story of Alexander’s origins.















[1] Belfast Newsletter, May 19th, 1826
[2] Marriages solemnized in the Parish of Armagh, County Armagh, 1823-1826, Church of Ireland, Armagh Parish records, MIC/583/12/138, Alexander Lockhart and Marie Richenet Marriage, 1826, Public Records Office of Northern Ireland (PRONI)
[3] Baptisms, Parish of Armagh, Armagh, County Armagh, 1823-1829, Church of Ireland, Armagh Parish records, MIC/583/12/138, John Lockhart, Baptism, 1827, PRONI
[4] Parish Register of Baptisms, St. Marylebone Parish Church, Saint Marylebone Road, London, Alexander Lockhart, baptism, 15 April 1829, FHL 580,912
[5] Henderson’s Directory, Belfast, 1846-47, 284-285
[6] Griffith Valuation, 1847-1864, www.originsnet.com/IrishOrigins/Search/Census/Griffiths/IOShowRecordsGri, viewed 06/16/2008
[7] R.S.J. Clark, Editor, Gravestone Inscriptions, Belfast, Vol. 1, (Belfast: Ulster Historical Foundation,  1982)
[8] Carlisle Patriot, 23 September, 1839
[9] Toby Musgrave, The Head Gardeners, Forgotten Heroes of Horticulture,  (London: Aurum Press Limited,  2007), viii
[10] Musgrave, ibid,   52
[11] Musgrave, ibid,  90
[12] Musgrave, ibid,  94
[13] Musgrave, ibid,  53
[14] The Gardener’s Magazine, 1828, vol IV, 32
[15] Musgrave, ibid, 102
[16] Helen Broderick, archivist trainee at Kew Gardens, Email to author, 31 October 2006 &  2 November, 2006
[17] Charles Nelson and Aidan Brady, ed, Irish Gardening and Horticulture, (Dublin: Royal Horticultural Society of Ireland,  1979)  105
[18] Sir Roderick Flood, Making and Running Great Gardens, 1700-1900, ,lecture given 20 June 2013 for Gresham College at www.gresham.ac.uk/lectures-and-events/making-and-running-great-gardens-1700-1900
[19]  Musgrave,  ibid, 57
[20] Gardener’s Magazine, 1826, 1; 10-14, J.C. Loudon, Self Education of Gardeners.
[21]  Musgrave, ibid,  58
[22] Musgrave, ibid, 60
[23] Musgrave, ibid,  60
[24]  Dr. Charles Nelson Email to author,  2 December, 2006
[25] Bradshaw’s Directory, (Armagh, 1819), Charles Lamb, Gardener to His Grace the Lord Primate, and Gardener’s Magazine, Vol. 10, p. 412, James Elles, obituary, Gardener to His Grace at Armagh, 1830-1934.
[26] Newry Commercial Telegraph, July 8, 1834.
[27]   Dr. Charles Nelson Email to author,  27 November, 2006
[28] Eileen McCracken, The Palm House and Botanic Garden, Belfast (Belfast: Ulster Architectural Heritage Society, Nicholson and Bass Ltd.,1971), 13
[29] Keith Lamb and Patrick Bowe, A History of Gardening in Ireland, (Dublin: National Botanic Gardens, Glasnevin,  1995) 59 
[30] Nelson and Brady, ibid,   54
[31] Ronald Webber, The Early Horticulturalists, (Newton Abbot: David and Charles) 1968, 25
[32] Garden History, Issue 3, Vol. 6
[33] Freeman’s Journal, 14 August, 1846. 3rd annual report (1850), Irish Poor Law Commissioners, p. 4 as quoted in   Nelson and  Brady, ibid, 80
[34] Eleanor Alexander, Lady Anne’s Walk, Edward Arnold, London, 1903
[35] Ann Sauders,  A Study of the Development of the Area of Regent’s Park from 1086 to the Present Day (Newton Abbot:  David and Charles, 1969) 154
[36] A.D. Webster, Regent’s Park and Primrose Hill, History and Antiquities (London: Greening & Co., Ltd. 1922) 11
[37] Webster, ibid, 82
[38] Michael Palmer, Archivist, Zoological Society of London, Email to author 14 October, 2006
[39] Sauders, ibid, 159
[40] Webster, ibid, 26